Receive a FREE Tybee Island 2019 Insider's Guide!

Order your free guide here.


Tybee Sugar Shack, Inc.

301 1st St., Tybee Island, GA 31328
Info & Amenities

The Sugar Shack -- A Tybee Tradition Since 1971!

  • Ice Cream
  • Desserts

TripAdvisor® Reviews:

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating
Jamie L | Aug 18, 2014
“Good service, terrible food.”

It was dinner time and the restaurant was empty, that should have been my first clue. The server was polite and fast, but the food was beyond disgusting! My wife just wanted a side salad, and she...

Elizabeth1516 | Aug 10, 2014
“Not so good”

The staff was great but the food was terrible. I had the shrimp dinner and it tasted as if it came from the freezer section at a grocery store. Really hate that the food fell short as we enjoyed the...

Robin P | Aug 10, 2014
“worst restaurant”

The worst experience ever! The peel and eat shrimp was inedible like rubber, and they even charge $2.25 for a glass of water! Who does that? Do not eat here!

Yelp® Reviews:

Yelp Overall Rating
KImberly B. | May 10, 2019

We had breakfast and then came back for ice cream later that day. The croissant sandwich was really good. A great place for a quick bite. Ice cream was great!

Kristen D. | Jun 6, 2019

Long line. Small portions compared to the price. Ice cream was good. Not much atmosphere to eat your ice cream.

Julie W. | Jun 4, 2019

Please quit writing on yelp and in articles that this is a Tybee staple that everyone needs to try because you trick newcomers like me into thinking it's...